STEMER Intellectual Property

View Original

"Ornamental" Rejections for Apparel Trademarks

A logo or brand printed on a shirt or baseball cap might not be a trademark.

The use of a brand in that way could be seen as a decoration, or merely “ornamental." The actual trademark is usually printed on the sewn-in tag or on the hang tag where you usually find the price. That is where the brand acts as a "source identifier.".

In order to qualify as a trademark, the brand must be a “source identifiers.” In other words, a consumer would have to be able to look at the branding and know which company is offering the goods or services. When a consumer sees a design on the front of the shirt, it might register as just a design. However, consumers know that the tags are where the brand name can be found. Sometimes, a brand on the front of a shirt or hat can act as a trademark, if the logo is not predominant and looks like a brand instead of a decoration.

This issue arises then new apparel companies come out with their first batch of clothes, but print their logo on the front of plain customizable clothing, such as Hanes or Gildan. The tags will still say “Hanes” or “Gildan.”

As part of the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) application process, you are required to show that your trademark is being used on your products as a source identifier. For apparel, a common option is to submit a photograph showing the trademark on an article of clothing. Unfortunately, if the photo only shows the brand name on the front of the shirt or hat in a way that looks like a decoration, you will likely receive a rejection from the USPTO. The only way to overcome the rejection is to show your brand name as a source identifier, such as on a hang tag or a sewn-in tag.